Cancer is an issue close to home for both candidates this November. McCain, the 72-year-old
Republican candidate, survived four malignant melanomas (skin cancers). Barack Obama, the 47-year-old
Democratic candidate, lost both his grandfather and mother to cancer.
"Despite achieving many life-saving advances, the war against cancer is an ongoing struggle that continues every day," said McCain (via a story in the Washington Post). "This is a fight we must and will win as a nation."
Obama describes his mother's cancer as "the most painful time of my life. She had ovarian cancer -- was diagnosed in February and was gone by November... It is not going to be easy to completely eliminate cancer but when I think about all the steps that we can take that we're not taking, it makes me frustrated. It's something that I will prioritize as president," he said.
Although both candidates claim to be on the same side of the war against cancer, the
Journal of Health Affairs published critiques of both candidates' health care plans.
McCain plans on eliminating income tax breaks for health insurance obtained through the workplace and instead give people a $2,500 tax credit for individuals who buy health insurance and a $5,000 tax credit for families that do so. The tax credit could help people buy insurance through their employer or in the individual market (licensed in any state). With more competition, costs would fall and quality would increase, McCain reasons.
The Journal warns that employers would be less likely to offer coverage if they knew their workers could get it elsewhere. The authors projected that 20 million people would lose their employer-sponsored insurance under McCain's plan, and 21 million people would gain coverage through the individual market. Another concern is that insurers would move to states with less onerous coverage requirements (i.e. insurers could relocate to one of the 30 states which don't require covering cervical cancer screenings).
Obama wants the government to provide health care for those who could not afford it otherwise. He wants to make it illegal to turn someone away because of pre-existing cancer, heart disease or diabetes. Furthermore, it would be illegal to charge a higher monthly premium because of any pre-existing conditions.
The journal argues that using third parties to subsidize the cost of a product exacerbates health inflation. "Any major expansion of coverage will be costly, and the Obama promise of affordability would require new, large, and rapidly growing federal subsidies that are unlikely to be sustainable, fiscally or politically," said the authors.
We encourage you to research the plans laid out by
McCain and
Obama; and use your vote to voice your opinion.